Code Stories · PressureTest
Seal depth is not in facts.json. Verbatim, 248 CMR 10.08(2)(e): "Each fixture trap shall have a liquid seal of not less than two inches and not more than four inches, except where for special conditions, a deeper seal may be required." 10.08(2)(c): "The following type traps are prohibited. 1. Traps which depend upon moving parts to maintain their seal. 2. Bell traps. 3. Crown vented traps. 4. Separate fixture traps which depend on interior partitions for their seal. 5. Full "S" traps."
Fixture outlet to trap weir vertical distance max 24 in. (248 CMR 10.08(2)(a)1.b)
Lavatory (common) trap 1-1/2 in. (248 CMR 10.08 Table 1)
Shower stall trap 2 in. minimum (248 CMR 10.08 Table 1)
Clothes washing machine connection trap 2 in. minimum (248 CMR 10.08 Table 1)
Kitchen sink, domestic trap 1-1/2 in. (248 CMR 10.08 Table 1)
The drain system is open to the sewer, and sewer air contains hydrogen sulfide, which ATSDR says can cause sudden unconsciousness or death above 500 ppm. It also deadens your sense of smell within minutes at around 100 ppm, so the smell is not a reliable warning.
A trap is the simplest barrier there is: a U-bend that always holds water, with no moving parts to wear out. The seal is only as good as the water in it.
Siphonage, evaporation, capillary attraction and back pressure can all empty it, which is why traps are paired with vents. Hidden partitions are banned because a cracked partition lets the seal go without any visible sign.
A 1940 federal manual gives exactly that reason.
Alexander Cumming receives the first English patent for a flushing water closet. It includes an S-shaped 'stink trap' that keeps water in the pipe.
Source: https://blog.sciencemuseum.org.uk/a-flushing-story/
Popular Science Monthly shows the era's belief that sewer air causes disease, and lists how traps lose their seals.
Source: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Popular_Science_Monthly/Volume_33/July_1888/Safety_in_House-Drainage
The same article states the miasma-era fear directly.
Source: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Popular_Science_Monthly/Volume_33/July_1888/Safety_in_House-Drainage
NBS Plumbing Manual (BMS 66) sets a trap seal of 2 to 4 inches.
Source: https://archive.org/stream/plumbingmanual66subc/plumbingmanual66subc_djvu.txt
BMS 66 explains why traps with hidden partitions are banned.
Source: https://archive.org/stream/plumbingmanual66subc/plumbingmanual66subc_djvu.txt
Amoy Gardens, Hong Kong. WHO investigators find that dried-out floor-drain traps let virus-laden droplets from the soil stack into bathrooms during the SARS outbreak.
Source: https://www.healthbureau.gov.hk/en/press_and_publications/press/2003/press030516.htm
Amoy Gardens, 2003: people mopped their bathroom floors instead of pouring water into the drains. The floor-drain traps dried out, and bathroom exhaust fans pulled droplets from the shared soil stack straight into the rooms. A trap with no water in it is not a trap.
Sewer gas is only a nuisance smell.
Hydrogen sulfide can kill at high concentrations and deadens smell after a few minutes' exposure (ATSDR). Amoy Gardens also showed that sewer-side aerosols can carry disease.
Germ theory proved the miasma-era plumbers wrong, so traps don't really matter.
Miasma theory was wrong about what causes disease. The barrier it produced is still essential against toxic gases and contaminated aerosols.
A deeper seal is always safer.
Massachusetts sets a maximum as well as a minimum: not more than 4 inches (248 CMR 10.08(2)(e)), the same figure the 1940 federal manual used. Deeper traps collect more sediment, and BMS 66 notes that every trap fouls under some conditions.
Every fixture trap must have a water seal of at least:
A trap seal is the only barrier keeping sewer gas out of the room. A seal shallower than 2 in. can be lost to minor siphonage, evaporation or wind gusts across the vent. 4 in. is the maximum seal, which students often confuse with the minimum.
The maximum water seal depth allowed in a fixture trap is:
A deeper seal holds more water, but the extra depth lets solids settle and stay there, and normal flow cannot scour the trap clean, so it fouls. 248 CMR therefore caps the seal at 4 in. except where a deeper seal is specifically permitted. 2 in. is the minimum seal, not the maximum.
Which trap type is prohibited?
In an S-trap the outlet drops straight down right after the weir, so the column of water leaving the trap pulls the seal out behind it (self-siphonage). A P-trap's horizontal arm to a vent breaks that siphon. Integral water closet traps are designed and approved as part of the fixture.
pressuretest.me/learn/traps-and-trap-seals/